FDBusiness.com

Belgium, France and Italy unite on positive botanicals list

 Breaking News
  • New Cost-saving Programme to Transform Arla Foods European dairy co-operative Arla Foods has launched an internal transformation programme called ‘Calcium’, which is set to deliver more than €400 million of savings by the end of 2020 through improved efficiency in all areas of the company. The programme looks to boost Arla’s performance to the benefit of its farmer-owners and further strengthen the [...]...
  • Ornua Appoints Chief Executive Designate The Board of Ornua, Ireland’s largest exporter of Irish dairy products, has appointed John Jordan as Chief Executive Designate. John Jordan will assume the role of Chief Executive on 30 June 2018 when he will succeed Kevin Lane, who announced his resignation as CEO on 12 December 2017. John Jordan is currently CEO of Ornua Foods [...]...
  • Nichols Invests £4.5 Million in Vimto Ross Factory UK-based soft drink group Nichols has unveiled a £4.5 million investment at its site in Ross-on-Wye (Vimto Ross). The newly-designed factory forms a key part of Vimto Out Of Home, manufacturing frozen and post-mix solutions for their own customers as well as for their external partners. Having acquired the site from Dayla in 2011, Vimto Ross [...]...
  • Bord Bia Welcomes Irish Beef Access to China Bord Bia (Irish Food Board) has welcomed the granting of access for Irish beef to China. Ireland is the first European beef exporter to secure access to China, where consumers’ appetite for the meat is growing steadily. According to Bord Bia, China officially imported more than 700,000 tonnes of beef in 2017 – a figure [...]...
  • HKScan Launches Pork Exports to China Leading Nordic food group HKScan has newly launched pork exports to China from its Forssa production unit. Within the first year of the launch, HKScan aims to ship roughly three million kilograms of pork to China and to subsequently triple that volume by 2020. Relative to the volume of pork currently produced annually in Finland, this [...]...

Belgium, France and Italy unite on positive botanicals list

April 25
11:59 2013

Belgian, French and Italian authorities have agreed a preliminary list of botanical substances for use in foods and supplements, after a meeting in Rome yesterday.

Italy has indicated it will write the list into law in July, with France and Belgium set to follow.

German representatives also expressed support for the project, based on national lists in the three countries with input from a European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) compendium that raises potential issues for about 900
herbals.

The European Commission’s Basil Mathioudakis also attended the meeting that may speed stalled EU-level harmonisation work around health claims and permitted substances.

The BELFRIT project, as it is called, was conceived at a meeting among plant science experts involved in the €6m EU-funded PlantLibra initiative, which is building a plant food science database, assessing safety and use and developing risk-benefit models.

Luca Bucchini, the managing director of Hylobates Consulting in Rome, was at the meeting and told us yesterday’s congress had been, “very good for the cause of botanicals.”

“The harmonised list is similar to EFSA’s compendium with the same experts that have worked on EFSA’s working group working with BELFRIT,” Bucchini said.

“It was particularly welcome that Germany’s Hartmut Waltner expressed appreciation for BELFRIT and, prodded by Basil Mathioudakis, indicated that Germany may be open to consider harmonised European legislation on botanicals that would prioritise safety and quality over claims.”

The move comes whilst botanical health claims are on hold at EU level, as the EC and member states deliberate what kind of science is appropriate to demonstrate their nutritional benefits.

About 1500 such claims were withdrawn from the nutrition and health claims regulation (NHCR) assessment process in September 2010 after some fierce lobbying from the sector that insisted the existing scientific protocols would significantly damage the industry by wiping out almost all claims.

The use of traditional use data

It may be years before a new approach is agreed upon, with the main issue being how to treat traditional use evidence, which is currently carries little sway with EFSA’s health claims panel.

“Several member states have asked EFSA to further assess the safety of botanicals, given that its earlier guidance on the safety of botanicals has not worked in practice,” said Bucchini.

“It remains to be seen how EFSA will respond to this request, and how they will combine modern risk assessment methodologies, the tradition-centric approach of BELFRIT, and emerging science from research, such as that of PlantLibra.”

He added: “Overall, it is difficult to predict if a compromise among member states will be found, and when. Italy has promised to use next year’s EU presidency to make further progress in this area. Frustration with mutual recognition has been expressed by officials present, as setting the lowest consumer protection standard, and this may spur action.”

The BELFRIT project was discussed at a botanical claims congress in Brussels yesterday, where legal experts and scientists picked over the treatment of botanicals under the NHCR, with one lawyer suggesting the EU approach may be in contravention of World Trade Organization (WTO) rules.

 

About Author

colin

colin

Related Articles



Food & Drink Business Conference & Exhibition 2016

Upcoming Events

  • April 24, 2018Scandinavian Wine Expo
  • April 24, 2018InterFood Krasnodar
  • April 24, 2018Seafood Processing Global
  • May 2, 2018The Food and Drink Trade Show
AEC v1.0.4

find food jobs

The Magazine

F&D Business Preferred Suppliers

New Subscriber





Subscribe Here



Advertisements